Attorneys and finance specialists collect tens of millions in fees.
By Keith Schneider
Circle of Blue
On July 18, 2013 Kevyn Orr, Detroit’s emergency manager, acted on the remarkably broad authorities afforded him by an eight-month-old state law and filed a petition to launch the largest municipal bankruptcy in U.S. history. Orr’s intent, he said, was to reduce the beleaguered city’s operating costs, reduce the cost of servicing the city’s debt, and set Detroit on a fresh course to redevelopment and prosperity.
During a news conference that evening, Detroit’s elected one-term Mayor Dave Bing stood meekly by Orr’s side and offered his reluctant support: “This is very difficult for all of us,” Bing said. “But if it’s going to make services better off, then this is a new start for us.”
In the more than 13 months since the bankruptcy petition was filed it’s become steadily clearer who’s better off in Detroit and who is not. The owners of small and medium-sized businesses that have invoices still to be paid by Detroit are not. They could receive 30 cents on the dollar or less on the outstanding balances.
The city’s 22,500 retired employees are not. They will experience pension cuts. About half the city’s general employees agreed to cut their pensions almost 5 percent, slash their health benefits 90 percent, and receive no cost of living adjustments. The other half – retired police and firefighters – will receive full pensions, but accepted a 55 percent reduction in cost of living adjustments and will receive only a small cash stipend to offset the cost of their new private health insurance plans.
Thousands of residents, many of them jobless and impoverished, also are not better off. They face losing their water again as a 37-day moratorium is lifted today and Detroit’s water department resumes cutting off water to property owners who are either $150 in arrears or 60 days late in paying their utility bills. Some 83,000 residences and businesses are said by the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department to owe $90 million to the utility.
“There’s lots of reasons why people have fallen behind,” said Baxter Jones, a city resident. “Some of my friends have had their water turned off. Some people that I know that have had to take their kids different places to wash up. It’s very, very sad when you think about it because there’s so many different reasons why you need water.”
But there’s another group, largely composed of professionals from outside Detroit and outside Michigan, who’ve benefited enormously from the Detroit bankruptcy, pocketing tens of millions in city payments from the circumstances that led to the pension reductions and water shutoffs.
A Shrinking City Under Emergency Rule
Detroit’s bankruptcy trial is scheduled to start Tuesday, September 2, in U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Steven Rhodes’ courtroom at the U.S. District Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Michigan. Over the next eight weeks or so, the trial proceedings are expected to reveal just how much “better off” the big banks financing the city’s new debt and financial obligations — as well the lawyers, bankers, accountants, and consultants involved in the deal-making — will be from rearranging Detroit’s fiscal operations.
An examination by Circle of Blue of the reports, exhibits, studies, and court orders filed with the federal bankruptcy court yields a disturbing and unassailable conclusion: While unionized employees lost jobs and substantial portions of their pensions and benefits, and thousands of Detroit’s poorest residents are severed from water supplies and sewer services, the nation’s biggest banks are making $6 billion to $7 billion in new bonds available to refinance city debts, a move that should reduce interest payments.
Meanwhile, tens of millions of dollars in transaction fees will be collected by bank officers. Traders selling the bonds could collect hundreds of millions of dollars more. And the regiment of lawyers and accountants handling the deals and managing the bankruptcy, at fees that range from $500 to $1,000 an hour, are collecting over $8 million a month for their services and expenses.
Making all of this possible is Michigan’s emergency manager law, hastily enacted by the Republican led state Legislature during an end-of-the-year lame duck session and signed by Michigan’s Republican Governor Rick Snyder in December 2012. The law authorizes the governor to appoint an unelected manager “with the tools needed to address a local unit’s financial emergency,” according to a fact sheet issued by Gov. Snyder. Those tools include expansive executive authority to oversee city departments, budgets, and finances without interference from mayors or city councils.
Gov. Snyder appointed Orr in mid-March 2013. Orr, who resigned his post as a senior partner at Washington-based Jones Day, one of the world’s largest law firms, was a legal team leader in the 2009 Chrysler bankruptcy. Gov. Snyder defends his appointment and the decisions of his Detroit emergency manager as necessary to ensure the city’s survival. “Now’s our opportunity to stop 60 years of decline,” he said on the day after the bankruptcy filing. “How long had this been going on and people were kicking the can down the road and not doing something? We’re doing something.”
Consultants involved in the bankruptcy case also see the value of Snyder’s appointment and Orr’s decision-making. “Detroit is at a tipping point,” wrote Martha E.M. Kopacz, a Boston-based management specialist who earned $535 an hour to evaluate the feasibility of the bankruptcy plan for the federal court. “While some may consider the chapter 9 filing as the low point in this great city’s history, I believe that it was the beginning of creating what can become a virtuous cycle of revitalization, improving economics and quality of life betterments for those who choose to live and work within the City. It is hard to imagine that people with such diverse political and socio-economic perspectives would have come together as they have in this process without the bankruptcy filing.”
Many city residents, labor organizers, academics and public interest lawyers evaluating the outcomes of Orr’s appointment do not hold similar views.
“What’s important for people to realize is that, although Detroit is the focus of attention because of its size and the scope of its problems, this is really an issue throughout Michigan,” said Curt Guyette, an investigative reporter for the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan. “The state’s emergency manager law, which is primarily being implemented in cities that have African-Americans as a majority and poverty rates that are much higher than average, is unique in its scope. Democratically elected officials at the local level are having their authority gutted. Collective bargaining agreements are being broken, diminishing the effectiveness of public service unions. Public assets are being privatized. Health care benefits for pensioners are being stripped away.
“We are also finding that in many of the cities under emergency management – cities such as Flint and Pontiac and Highland Park – the issue of water affordability has become an increasing concern. The problems are all linked together.”
Indeed, the costs of operating Detroit’s drinking water and sewage treatment systems have steadily risen even as demand for water and sewer services and the number of water department employees has fallen. The cost of paying debt service on more than $5 billion in bonded debt — $428.4 million annually – represents 45 percent of the water department’s $948.6 million budget this year and is the department’s single largest expense, according to city figures. (see sidebar)
Many less people in Detroit are being asked to pay more towards those costs. Detroit has lost hundreds of thousands of jobs and an average of 20,000 residents annually have departed since 1954, when the city’s population peaked. That has left under 700,000 residents, and one-third as many property and business owners, to pay water and sewer expenses designed for a city that once had nearly two million residents. Before a rate increase in July the cost of water and sewer averaged around $65 a month for most households, according to the water department, but water prices are rising faster than most cities. The average overdue water and sewer bill is under $540, the department said.
The capacity to pay water bills in a city that has low median incomes and jobless rates that approach 20 percent is diminishing. “We’re organizing all over the city to stop the water shutoffs and show what’s really going on,” said Alice Jennings, a Detroit attorney who filed a case in July with the bankruptcy court to halt the water cutoffs. “Why are you going against these people who owe these $150 water bills that have families and children instead of looking at how much these banks and these consultants are making?”
That question prompted Judge Rhodes to raise similar concerns. Rhodes held a hearing on July 17 to express alarm about the attention the water shutoffs were generating around the world. He told Darryl Latimer, the deputy director of Detroit Water and Sewerage Department, to offer more repayment options. “You are aware your shutoff program has created a lot of anger and hardship, not to mention scores of bad publicity the city doesn’t need?” Rhodes said. “It’s hurting the city and this bankruptcy. Is there more the department can do to make the payment plans accessible?”
Millions in Lawyers’ Fees
The judge’s hearing produced a small wave of action. The water department suspended the shutoffs. Before the suspensions the department had turned off service to 17,000 residences this year, prompting about half to pay their bills, according to city records.
On July 28 Emergency Manager Orr issued an order that returned control of DWSD to the city and Mayor Mike Duggan. On August 7 Mayor Duggan announced a new 10-point program of relief that included expanded financial assistance for those who can’t afford to pay their water bills, and measures to ensure residents know when their water is in danger of getting turned off.
Meanwhile, as the opening of the bankruptcy trial approaches, there are no parched throats in the offices and hotel suites of the bankers, attorneys, and court-appointed experts.
Under the emergency manager’s guidance Detroit authorized at least $133.6 million to be paid in 2014 and 2015 for fees associated with the bankruptcy proceedings, according to court records. Judge Rhodes appointed a fee manager, Chicago bankruptcy specialist and attorney Robert Fishman, to review invoices and publish a quarterly report. His firm’s blended hourly rate for its work is $430 an hour, plus expenses.
According to the latest filing by Fishman for fees from July 2013 to March 2014, 16 consulting firms, law firms, and finance experts have filed invoices for $54.2 million in fees and $2.4 million in expenses.
By far the largest invoices are from Jones Day, Orr’s former law firm, which filed for $22.2 million in fees and $590,248 in expenses for its work from July to February. Jones Day did not submit invoices for fees in March 2014. Moreover before July 2013, Jones Day submitted invoices to the city for almost $8 million more in fees.
The Washington-based firm is seeking payments that average around $3 million a month. Jones Day lawyers earn up to $1,000 an hour and are filing for expenses that include $183-per-night hotel rooms, $1,000 flights from Washington to New York, $60 taxi rides and dinners at $40-per-plate and more.
Another law firm, Dentons US LLP of New York, billed for $7.4 million in fees and $365,000 in expenses from July 2013 to March 2014. Dentons is litigating the settlement with Detroit’s pensioners and charges fees for its lawyers who are living and traveling in style as they earn up to $930 an hour. The firm regularly files for $218-per-night hotel rooms at the Westin Book Cadillac, and $195 limousine charges to transport one of its partners from their Stamford, Connecticut home to and from LaGuardia airport. Denton’s lawyers routinely paid nearly $1,500 for round trip flights to Detroit from New York and Washington. Denton lawyers also are filing for their hourly fees as they travel on flights to Detroit and back, and trains to Washington and back, fees that typically exceed $2,400 a day, according to their invoice.
The attorneys and experts with Miller Buckfire, a New York-based investment banking firm advising Detroit on restructuring nearly $6 billion in bond payments, filed for $3.625 million in fees from July 2013 to March 2014, and $190,765 in expenses. Miller Buckfire is handling negotiations with major investors to restructure the $5.9 billion in secured water and sewer bonds the city accumulated over the last several decades. Detroit capped Miller Buckfire’s fee at $28 million according to an agreement it reached last year.
The big banks readying new city debt also are set to rake in tens of millions of dollars. Upwards of $6 billion in new financing is under discussion in the bankruptcy filings. According to bond traders, underwriting fees to the banks now typically amount to $5 per $1,000, or $5 million per $1 billion. Earlier this year, for example, Puerto Rico authorities disclosed that the banks that managed its recent sale of $3.5 billion in bonds pocketed $28.1 million in transactional fees.
The Detroit bond sale is likely to net Bank of America, UBS, Morgan Stanley, and several more financial institutions $50 million or more in fees. Bond traders could earn $100 million or more in fees and commissions from selling Detroit’s new debt.
In effect, Detroit’s bankruptcy is producing thousands of losers, and a small group of winners — the professionals charged with carrying out the orders of the city’s emergency manager. The array of financially troubled cities in Michigan also make the state a potentially huge new market for municipal bankruptcies, and a deep pool for the extravagant fees generated from refinancing decades of industrial decline.
Keith Schneider is Circle of Blue's senior editor and chief correspondent based in Traverse City, Michigan. He developed the Global Choke Point project and has reported on the contest for energy, food, and water in the era of climate change from six continents.
Email: Keith Schneider :: Follow on Twitter :: More Articles