Circle of Blue
  • Podcasts
  • Great Lakes
  • Water Debt
  • WaterNews
    • WaterNews
      • The Daily Stream
      • Federal Water Tap
      • Weekly Water Newsletter
      • Convenings
    • Current
      • Water, Texas
      • Coronavirus
      • Legionnaires’
      • Australia
      • Fair Bluff
      • After Paradise Burned
      • Water Scarcity in India
      • Michigan’s Groundwater Emergency
      • Groundwater
      • Water Pricing
      • Water Affordability
      • Delhi Waits For Water
  •  Special Features
    •  
      • Water and Financial Risks
      • Stranded Assets
      • Lake Mead
      • Cape Town
      • Flint Water Crisis
      • California Drought
      • Global WaterViews on QlikView
      • Himalayas
      • Hidden Waters, Dragons in the Deep
      • Designing Waters Future
      • Zeropolis
        • Big Cities, Little Water
      • Water and Climate
      • Septic Infrastructure in the U.S.
      • Unearthing Water Risks of The Global Mining Industry
      • Chennai
  • HotSpots H2O
  • Choke Point
    • The World at a Choke Point
      • Choke Point: Australia
      • Choke Point: Tamil Nadu
      • Choke Point: South Africa
      • Choke Point: China
      • Choke Point: India
      • Choke Point: Australia
      • Choke Point: Tehuacán Valley
    • Choke Point: U.S.
      • Choke Point: Index
        • California Central Valley
        • Great Lakes Algae
        • Ogallala Aquifer
        • Water Data
  • About
    • About Circle of Blue
      • Team Members
      • Board of Directors
      • Internships
      • Ethics and Sponsorship
      • Underwriters
      • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Search
  • Menu

Drip by Drip, Septic Systems Foul Michigan Waters

  • Michigan’s Groundwater Emergency
  • PFAs by the Numbers
  • Remembering the PBB Crisis
  • Groundwater and Growth
  • Septic Systems Foul Michigan Waters

The state relies on backyard sewage treatment more than most.

More than one million Michigan households use septic systems, a higher rate than the national average. Failing and outdated systems introduce unwanted nitrogen, cleaning chemicals, pharmaceutical compounds, and bacteria to the state’s waters. © J. Carl Ganter/Circleofblue.org

By Brett Walton, Circle of Blue

Out of sight and often neglected, Michigan’s more than one million septic systems are an overlooked health and environmental risk for the state’s groundwater, rivers, and lakes, and the people who use them.

Modern and well-maintained systems adequately cleanse household sewage. But potentially hundreds of thousands of leaky, broken, or outdated units are injecting unwanted nitrogen, pharmaceutical compounds, household chemicals, and bacteria into state waters.

A recent Michigan State University study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in 2015 found that septic systems were the primary contributor to elevated levels of fecal bacteria in 64 Michigan watersheds.

“Whatever we put in our septic systems is headed to our groundwater and surface waters of Michigan,” says David Cotton, director of the onsite wastewater program at the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ).

Because Michigan is one of the few states without a septic code that applies to all residential development, the Legislature is considering two bills that would allow the Department of Environmental Quality to set baseline standards for the design and placement of these backyard sewage treatment units.

For now, a patchwork of rules, mostly written by county health departments, governs septic system installation, maintenance, and repair. A state standard would be beneficial, Cotton said, by establishing a minimum level of performance for all systems and reducing environmental and health risks.

A state standard would bring state and local policy closer to the physical reality of how water moves through the landscape, argues Dave Dempsey, a senior adviser with FLOW, a Traverse City-based advocacy group and environmental advisor in the 1980s to former Gov. James Blanchard.

“Groundwater is treated like a second-class citizen because the connection to surface water is not seen,” Dempsey told Circle of Blue.

Glen Lake aerial photo from ArcGIS. Credit: Cecelia Denton

From Temporary to Permanent

The old thinking, decades ago, when the Clean Water Act was passed in 1972, was that septic systems would be a temporary fix, Cotton explained to Circle of Blue. Backyard units that trap solid waste in a tank and allow the liquid to percolate into the soil would suffice until public sewers could be extended to farm junctions, forest nooks, and isolated subdivisions.

In the 1990s, local and state leaders realized that sewer systems were not going to reach as far into suburban and rural America as centralized electric grids had two generations earlier. Federal construction grants that helped build sewage treatment after the Clean Water Act were not renewed and had been replaced with a smaller loan program. Utilities, county commissioners, and homeowners often recoiled at the price tag of extending sewer service: sometimes as high as $40,000 to $60,000 per home, Cotton said. The temporary fix turned out to be permanent. As Cotton puts it: “The sewer was not coming.”

Michigan relies on septic systems more than most. One-fifth of U.S. households use a septic tank, compared to one-in-three in Michigan. And the number of systems in the state is growing. Half of new homes employ septic tanks, according to Cotton.

Comprehensive and well-organized data on septic system locations and conditions are notoriously difficult to obtain. The last thorough accounting of septic systems nationally was the 1990 census. Michigan still extrapolates from those numbers — by factoring in population growth — to estimate the number of statewide systems, which Cotton says is between 1.3 million and 1.4 million.

How many of the older systems are malfunctioning is even harder to reckon. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency offers a ballpark figure: that roughly 10 percent of systems are failing. Data collected in two Michigan counties suggest a larger problem.

In 2007, the Barry-Eaton District Health Department began overseeing a local ordinance that required a septic system inspection before selling a home. Until that point, the department, which directs health programs for the two counties southwest of Lansing, had guidelines for system construction, but no way of evaluating performance after years in the ground.

The ordinance revealed long-buried problems. Of the nearly 10,000 sewage systems that were assessed, more than one in four — 27 percent — needed a major or minor repair. There were unwelcomed surprises, too. Five hundred thirty-three properties had a makeshift sewage system — a pipe leading to an oil drum, hollowed-out car, pit, or other jury-rigged contraption — or no system at all.

Over a decade, the time-of-sale regulation “identified numerous, significant problems with wells and sewage systems that pose a threat to public and environmental health,” according to a health department evaluation.

“It’s all connected,” Cotton said, referring to the state’s waters. “Whether you build it right or not, the liquid in the septic system is recharging streams and groundwater.”

Nonetheless, the ordinance encountered opposition from those who viewed the inspections as an intrusion on private property rights and the cost of mandatory repairs as a financial strain and obstacle to selling a home. It was a classic political conundrum: individual rights against communal costs. In the end, the Board of Commissioners for Barry and Eaton counties voted in March to repeal the ordinance.

Reforms Coming?

This is the status of Michigan’s septic system regulation: a convoluted patchwork of state laws, but with oversight largely carried out at the local level. The state regulates the placement of commercial systems with more than 1,000 gallons of flow per day and high-density residential areas. Single-family homes and duplexes are mainly exempt.

By and large, it is the 44 county and district health departments that regulate septic systems for single-family residential homes. The rules vary widely. Before Barry and Eaton decided to repeal the time-of-sale ordinance, 11 county health departments had such rules.

Other jurisdictions are not so vigilant. Cotton noted that some counties have no requirements to test whether the soil is suitable. Septic systems require relatively dry soils that percolate water and are not clay. The Natural Resources Conservation Service estimates that 92 percent of the state’s soils are “very limited” in their suitability for traditional, buried septic systems that use a tank and a drain field. That means specialized systems will be necessary and “poor performance and high maintenance” should be expected, NRCS says.

But few counties have such rigorous standards.

“One problem is that the rules can be as strict or as lenient as the counties want to make them,” Terry Gibb told Circle of Blue. Gibb runs educational programs on septic systems for Michigan State University Extension.

Cotton said that the DEQ drafted revised standards in 2013 for commercial systems. The department has accepted those standards as a final, but it is waiting on the Legislature to authorize the change. The governor’s office is also interested in an updated code. Sustaining Michigan’s Water Heritage, a document prepared by five state agencies and released two years ago, recommended a state law to require periodic septic system inspections.

Two bills that together would authorize the DEQ, in consultation with an advisory council, to write a statewide septic code were filed in March in the Michigan House of Representatives. Neither has moved out of committee. Rep. Jim Lower, who sponsored one of the bills, said that was partly due to disagreements with local health departments about a provision that would have banned and repealed time-of-sale rules like those in Barry and Eaton counties.

Lower, who has seen his district’s Pine River fouled by bacteria from leaking septic systems, said that revised language will allow time-of-sale ordinances but not require repairs before the home is sold.

Lower is hopeful that the septic bills will pass before the end of the session, in December. But he realizes that the competition for legislative attention will be intense.

“There are a lot of bills, the session window is closing, and everyone has their priorities,” he told Circle of Blue. “But the governor’s office has said that this is a priority, and we’ll try to get it done.”

Brett Walton

Brett writes about agriculture, energy, infrastructure, and the politics and economics of water in the United States. He also writes the Federal Water Tap, Circle of Blue’s weekly digest of U.S. government water news. He is the winner of two Society of Environmental Journalists reporting awards, one of the top honors in American environmental journalism: first place for explanatory reporting for a series on septic system pollution in the United States(2016) and third place for beat reporting in a small market (2014). He received the Sierra Club’s Distinguished Service Award in 2018. Brett lives in Seattle, where he hikes the mountains and bakes pies. Contact Brett Walton

Related

Recent Posts

  • Congress on Track to Approve Millions More in Federal Funding for Water Debt Relief
  • The Stream, February 25, 2021: Judge Needs More Time To Review Arguments In Flint Water Crisis Case
  • Michigan Rivers Changing Due to Climate Disruption
  • Climate Change is Affecting The Kind of Fish You Can Catch in Michigan’s Inland Lakes
  • The Stream, February 24, 2021: Chicago Backs Deal To Supply Lake Michigan Water To Joliet

Subscribe: Weekly Waternews

* indicates required
Please also subscribe me to the daily Stream
Please also subscribe me to the Federal Water Tap

© 2020 Circle of Blue – all rights reserved
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy

Donate to Circle of Blue
Fastest-Growing Michigan County Reckons With Groundwater Pollution and Depl... Remembering Michigan’s PBB Crisis
Scroll to top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

OKLearn more

Cookie and Privacy Settings

How we use cookies

We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, you cannot refuse them without impacting how our site functions. You can block or delete them by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website.

Google Analytics Cookies

These cookies collect information that is used either in aggregate form to help us understand how our website is being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are, or to help us customize our website and application for you in order to enhance your experience.

If you do not want that we track your visist to our site you can disable tracking in your browser here:

Other external services

We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Google Map Settings:

Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

Make an impact this #GivingNewsDay
Journalism with this kind of impact is free to consume but costly to produce.
Support fact-based journalism with your tax-deductible donation
For a limited time, NewsMatch will match your gift, dollar for dollar
Support Independent Journalism
You have the power to inform the world's most important decisions
with your tax-deductible donation
 Tweet
 Copy
 E-mail
 Tweet
 Copy
 E-mail
 Tweet
 LinkedIn
 Copy
 E-mail